≡ Menu

Updated guidelines for LEGO Ideas projects

Last week LEGO updated their Guidelines and House Rules and Terms of Service to clarify the range of submissions that would make good candidates for LEGO Ideas sets. This includes new limits to project size, scope, and subject matter, as well as simplified guidelines for collaborative projects. LEGO Ideas is a very innovate initiative from the company that allows LEGO fans to submit their own ideas for future LEGO sets. Unfortunately the platform has been cluttered by submissions that do not fit with the parameters and requirements of the LEGO Company. This made LEGO Ideas less interesting and relevant to supporters. Hopefully the updated guidelines will help clear up the platform and give way to projects that could actually be made into official LEGO sets. Below is a summary of the updates from the LEGO Ideas website.

LEGO Ideas Rules
  • Once we produce a LEGO Ideas set based on a third-party property, we will not accept more Ideas submissions based on that property. This sharpens our guideline on follow-up products based on LEGO Ideas submissions. Once we approve a licensed project for production through LEGO Ideas, we’ll archive other projects based on the same property and not accept new submissions based on the that property.
  • Projects must fit in a single product box, so we’re setting a part count limit of 3,000 pieces. While we can’t count the pieces in your photos, if your model looks too big we’ll send it back and ask you to submit a smaller model at our own discretion.
  • Projects must focus on a single concept or third-party property. This essentially expands on the “no play-themes or series” rule and also rules out “mass customization” projects (e.g. custom mosaic or minifigure makers) as well as combining more than one third-party property into a single project. (e.g. a project containing both Porsche and Ferrari cars).
  • It’s now simpler to collaborate on projects. We’ve removed the requirement to email us declaring your collaboration. You must still receive explicit permission from someone else before including their original work in your project. All new collaborative projects must mention collaborators’ LEGO Ideas usernames in the description, and state that their original work is included with the member’s explicit permission.
  • New restrictions on project contents
    • No iconic elements referencing third-party properties we find inappropriate for the LEGO brand
    • No large or human-scale weapons or weapon replicas of any kind, including swords, knives, guns, sci-fi or fantasy blasters, etc.
    • Projects may not propose LEGO Dimensions expansion packs
    • You may only use logos that belong to third parties in the context of your model, similar to LEGO logo guidelines. You may not display logos that do not belong to you in your artwork, since this can imply endorsement from the logo owner.
  • New guidelines to help improve project descriptions
    • At minimum, please write your description to include a description of your model, why you built it, and why you believe it would make a great LEGO set.
    • In some cases, moderators may make basic grammatical changes on your behalf so we can speed up the approval of your project. We will never change the nature of your project and we’ll notify you by email if we make any changes.
  • Terms of Service now preserves projects that gain a significant following. While we understand you may occasionally want to delete a project with only a handful of supporters, to either re-submit with improvements or clean up your project portfolio, once a project reaches 1,000 supporters it will not be removed.
  • Terms of Service revises language regarding assignment of rights. We’ve worked with our Legal department to clarify how you assign us rights when you submit a project, and reassure you that you may share and publish your submission to promote your project online, in media, your portfolio, and other places for non-commercial purposes.

We introduce these guidelines with the following steps:

  1. New Guidelines and moderation responses
  2. Archiving projects based on third-party properties commercialized through LEGO Ideas, including Hayabusa, Minecraft, Back to the Future, Mars Science Laboratory Curiosity Rover, Ghostbusters, The Big Bang Theory, Doctor Who, WALL-E, Caterham, Adventure Time, Beatles, and Apollo missions.
  3. Removing projects that don’t fit our new appropriate content requirements such as life-sized weapons or references to inappropriate third-party properties
  4. Other guidelines will be applied going forward and not retroactively

Why these updates now?

We write our Guidelines to help you submit projects that have a reasonable chance of being selected as a product in our LEGO Review. The paradox is that we can only learn what is possible to produce through LEGO Ideas by evaluating a wide range of projects and identifying project attributes that fit our capabilities over time.

You’ve also shared opinions and suggestions about how to make LEGO Ideas an even better experience. We feel fortunate to have a passionate community that strives for this as much as we do. While we can’t accommodate every wish, your collective feedback has been incredibly valuable in making these changes to improving LEGO Ideas for as many as possible.

Throughout the rest of 2016 and beyond, our team is working to improve the way we engage on the platform and social media, improving our internal LEGO Review process, and working on the overall long-term growth of the LEGO Ideas experience.

LEGO CUUSOO to LEGO Ideas

As you can see, one of the most important updates is that projects that are too big will no longer be accepted. People naturally vote for large models because they look impressive, but they don’t take into consideration how much these models would actually cost, or if they could even be boxed and sold as sets. This means that large models often gather the minimum required number of votes, only to be rejected at the end, and disappointing both the original submitter and the supporters. This new guideline should keep projects in a reasonable range and make it clear to everyone what is realistic for LEGO to work with. It is interesting to note that LEGO set the upper limit to 3000 pieces. That’s like a $250-$300 big set! So far LEGO Ideas sets have all been smaller, but it looks like LEGO would be happy to accept larger submissions as well – as long as they are not too large.

Shop LEGO Ideas Maze

Another important update is related to IPs, and new projects similar to those that already became official LEGO sets. Often when a LEGO Ideas project is approved, a whole bunch of similar submissions pop up on LEGO Ideas – basically trying to ride the coattail of the successful project. This clutters up the LEGO Ideas platform with a bunch of copycat submissions, which makes navigating the site difficult.

Hopefully these updates will make the LEGO Ideas platform more useful for both those who submit new projects, and those who support them. What do you think? How do you like the new rules? Is there anything else you think would make LEGO Ideas better? Feel free to share your thoughts in the comment section below! To see the currently available LEGO Ideas sets originally submitted by LEGO fans visit the LEGO Ideas section of the the LEGO Ideas section of the Online LEGO Shop.

Shop LEGO Ideas

And you might also like to check out the following related posts:

{ 12 comments }

A LEGO fan’s encounters with Mega Bloks

While I have been a LEGO fan all my life, my introduction to building toys similar to LEGO is quite recent. I originally started paying attention to other brands about eight years ago when I was working on some customized minifigures. At that time LEGO didn’t have such an extensive selection of minifig accessories, so I looked for products from LEGO customizers and LEGO compatible brands. One such brand that caught my attention was Mega Bloks. And here I’m going to narrate to you my journey to the dark side of flirting with LEGO’s main competitor… 🙄

LEGO & Mega Bloks

Although there are some really high quality LEGO compatible brands, they are usually difficult to find in the USA, and when imported from overseas prices are just as expensive as LEGO, if not more. On the other hand, Mega Bloks is readily available at most department stores and toy stores, and they are helpfully (or sneakily) placed right next to LEGO boxes. So I kept running into Mega Bloks sets on my LEGO shopping trips.

LEGO vs. Mega Bloks Toys

I was especially eyeing Mega Bloks’ castle and fantasy lines, like the Dragons, King Arthur, Chronicles of Narnia and Word of Warcraft sets. The artwork on the boxes always looked awesome with great castles, beautiful ships, and armored warriors. Mega Bloks boxes usually have at least one main character exposed via a clear window, and unfortunately the real figures compared to the box-art didn’t look nearly as impressive. In addition, I also read that Mega Bloks was inferior quality, they are a LEGO clone brand, and LEGO fans suppose to hate them. So I shied away from buying any of the sets.

LEGo & Mega Bloks King Arthur

Around this time I had a young friend named Julien who used to come over to our house to play with my LEGO collection from time to time. He was a really talented young builder who had good eyes for both design and color, and I was impressed by his creations. His family eventually moved away, and later when I talked with him on the phone he said he switched over to Mega Bloks because he liked their figures better. I was quite surprised that one of my young LEGO buddies would join the dark side of building toys. But I also knew he had good taste and appreciated good quality, so I started looking at Mega Bloks again with more interest.

My first Mega Bloks purchase was a couple of years ago when I got all four of the Halo Metallic Series ODST Drop Pods that were available at that time. I was at the LEGO isle (of course) at Wal-Mart, and I came across some opened packages (probably by curious kids) of the Mega Bloks Halo Drop Pods, so I had a chance to take a look at some of the figures outside the packaging. I thought that they looked quite good, so I bought all four of them from the collection. I wanted to examine them more, and maybe review them for our readers. I ended up really liking these figures. They are basically small, 2-inch tall action-figures, with excellent articulation, great details, and really good quality.

LEGO & Mega Bloks Halo Metallic

Shortly after I got the Call of Duty Desert Troopers set with five figures and a bunch of accessories. These figures were also excellent quality, but the tiny pieces really tested my patience. Basically every little accessory you see on the figures is a separate piece you need to attach. The weapons are also made up of tiny pieces that you assemble yourself. On the positive side, this makes the set extremely versatile and customizable, on the negative side dealing with so many small parts is tedious to say the least. Later I learned that the Call of Duty sets are unique in this regard, but at that point, even though I liked the figures, I stopped buying Mega Bloks for a while.

LEGO & Mega Bloks Desert Troopers

The next sets I got were from the Hot Wheels line. Three little vehicles with a driver for each. They looked good on the boxes, but what I found inside was just terrible. The parts had ugly colors and not at all what was displayed on the boxes, and the pieces had such bad clutch-power that they were constantly falling off. The figures were ugly too. My budding faith in the Mega Bloks brand was shaken, and I stopped even looking at them.

LEGO & Mega Bloks Hot Wheels

After some time however, I discovered that my favorite LEGO reviewer, JANGBRiCKS, was also doing reviews on Mega Bloks sets. I learned that Mega Bloks actually have what they call the Collectors line, with much higher quality than their standard sets. The Halo and Call of Duty sets I got from them previously were from the Collectors line, whereas the Hot Wheels cars were standard Mega Bloks sets. Ahhh! That made sense! I also found out that Mega Bloks has a separate dedicated website for their Collectors line, and the first products they carried for collectors was from Halo back in 2009. Then they later added Call of Duty, Assassin’s Creed, Terminator, and Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles. And this year Destiny and Star Trek was also added. The website looks tasteful and very well organized, so I spent some time studying what they had, and I also watched pretty much all of JANGBRiCKS reviews on the Collectors sets (below are some samples).

I was back fully flirting with LEGO’s competitor. However even within the Collectors line I didn’t have an interest in the sets. Most of them depict modern military scenes and vehicles, which I don’t care about. Plus I much prefer LEGO’s refined building system and consistent color-palette for actual building. At the same time, I was definitely interested in the high quality and highly detailed figures, as I always liked small action figures. (Mega Bloks calls them Micro Action Figures.)

LEGO & Mega Bloks Destiny LEGO & Mega Bloks Star Trek

The next thing I bought were all four Ninja Turtles from the Mega Blocks TMNT Collectors line. I have reviewed these separately here: Mega Bloks Treasures for LEGO TMNT Fans. I’m not going to repeat what I wrote previously, but in summary, I was very impressed and very happy with the figures, and I also really liked the accessories and beautifully printed tiles (all fully LEGO compatible). I’m looking forward to the black-and-white early comic book version of the characters coming out later this year.

LEGO and Mega Bloks Ninja Turtles 3 LEGO and Mega Bloks Ninja Turtles 5

Then, I got all six of the Halo Heroes Series 1 figures that were recently released. As I mentioned previously, the Halo franchise is the oldest in the Mega Bloks Collectors line, so there are a huge amount of sets and characters. I already had the four I got previously, but Mega Bloks refined the articulation of the shoulders since then, and I wanted to get some of the newer figures as well. Halo Heroes Series 1 (and later this year Series 2 will be released as well) make a nice collection and are good examples of the entire line. While very nicely detailed, the Halo figures are not so heavily accessorized as in Call of Duty. You don’t have to worry about loosing small pieces, or having to manually assemble tiny accessories. While the armor pieces can be exchanged, the only external accessories are one-piece weapons. Much more favorable for play.

LEGo & Mega Bloks Halo Series 1 LEGO & Mega Bloks Halo Series 2

Around the same time I also picked up the Mega Bloks Call of Duty Icarus Troopers set with five astronauts. I know I said I don’t like the Call of Duty sets as much because – while the figures are excellent – there are too many tiny accessories. But I really liked these astronauts, and in this case only the weapons are made up of small parts. I didn’t really care about arming my astronauts, and only needed them for peaceful space exploration.

LEGO & Mega Bloks Icarus Troopers

Two more figures that I got are from the Mega Bloks Assassin’s Creed line. Even if you are not into the video-game this is an excellent collection of Red Coats, Blue Coat, pirates and other history/fantasy figures. The only two that I picked up are these two gorgeous looking knights in beautifully detailed medieval armor! These are my most favorite Mega Bloks figures. The designers really outdid themselves! I really hope that Mega Bloks will bring back more medieval/fantasy sets under their Collectors line.

LEGO & Mega Bloks Knights

Now that I know the difference between the Collectors line and regular Mega Bloks sets, I have been consistently happy with my purchases. Having said that, there are some standard Mega Bloks sets that I think are worth checking out. Particularly the Smurfs and Minions. The sets are inferior quality, but the figures are very cute. You can get them in small packets with a few accessories, so you don’t have to bother with buying entire sets. And you can incorporate both the figures and accessories into your LEGO creations.

LEGO vs. Mega Bloks Details LEGO & Mega Bloks Minions

So far I only bought boyish Mega Bloks sets. So do they have anything nice for girls? I do remember seeing some Mega Bloks Barbie sets, but the figures looked dreadful. However the recently released Monster High characters are pretty cute – if you are into teenage girls in ghoulish outfits.

LEGO & Mega Bloks Monster High

The collection that really caught my attention in the girly department is the new Mega Bloks American Girl sets. They are not within the Collectors line, but it is clear that Mega Bloks put serious effort into making these sets as nice as possible. I don’t have any of the full sets, however I did get all eight of the Series 1 Collectible Figures Assortment. The figures are fully articulated tiny versions of the classic American Girl dolls. They can be completely taken apart and all parts can be exchanged, so you can basically mix and match all their clothing. The hair pieces can be exchanged as well. The skirts and hats are made of a rubbery element that is quite nice. The figures are high quality and look cute – maybe not as sweet looking as the LEGO Friends mini-dolls, but definitely cuter that the old LEGO Belville dolls. In size they are somewhere in between LEGO Friends and LEGO Belville. LEGO Friends mini-dolls are less than 2 inches high, whereas the American Girl dolls are 2.5 inches, so their hair and clothing pieces are not compatible. However their handheld accessories can be used by LEGO minifigures (and vice versa).

LEGO & Mega Bloks American Girl

Mega Bloks is sort of a mix between traditional toy soldiers and miniature dolls displayed on terrain pieces, and construction toys like LEGO. This means that their figures are more realistic, but because pretty much every Mega Bloks product-line has its own style and scale of characters, their parts can’t be switched as easily (if at all) as for LEGO minifigures. There is one feature of Mega Bloks figures however that is systematically the same; their hands can hold the same accessories, and their feet can stand on studs – and both of these features are compatible with LEGO’s system. In other words, all handheld Mega Bloks figure accessories are compatible with LEGO minifigures, and Mega Bloks figures can stand on LEGO studs.

LEGO & Mega Bloks Comparison

Because Mega Bloks is not a systemized construction toy like LEGO, their building elements are not always compatible with each other, nor can they be easily mixed to build your custom creations. They do have some basic building blocks that are copied from LEGO that can be used for free-building, but they also have a lot of specialized large pieces that only serve one purpose. In addition, their colors are not standardized, and can be all over the place, which further makes Mega Bloks a bad choice for custom models. Having said that, you can find some interesting small pieces in Mega Bloks sets that LEGO doesn’t make.

LEGO & Mega Bloks Quality

The quality of the pieces however is not nearly as good as LEGO. Even in the Collectors line, it is only the figures that are high quality. The rest of the parts feel cheap, and are very inconsistent in both color and clutch-power. Some are way too tight, others are too lose. Their size tolerance is also much worse than LEGO. Pieces next to each other have weird and inconsistent gaps in between. I have only been focusing on getting the Micro Action Figures, but because some of them came in regular sets, I had a chance to try out the quality of standard pieces as well. If you are a LEGO fan and used to LEGO’s quality, I wouldn’t recommend them. However if you are interested in any of the sets, I would suggest that you first pick up a small set in the same line to see how you like the quality.

LEGO & Mega Bloks TMNT

While Mega Bloks does have a website where all their current products, product descriptions, and prices are listed, they do not directly sell online like LEGO does via the Online LEGO Shop. You have to buy all their sets through third-party retailers. Prices are usually slightly lower than LEGO’s, although they have been creping up. I have found that Toys’R’Us has the best selection of Mega Bloks sets, and it is a good place to check out their selection. Wal-Mart also has a decent selection, although not nearly as extensive as Toys’R’Us. However now that I know what I like, I pretty much just use the Mega Bloks website for researching new sets, check out JANGBRiCKS reviews on them, and then buy what I want on eBay or Amazon. Prices are often better than at retail stores, and you can also buy the figures individually. Here are some of the listings I have been using. You can find them here:

In summary, I would say that while Mega Bloks as a building system doesn’t come near the quality of LEGO, their Micro Action Figures in the Collectors line are excellent. The characters do look really good, are a pleasure to collect and display, and durable enough for regular play. And the fact that they are compatible with LEGO studs and accessories could make them attractive even for LEGO fans. It seems like Mega Bloks finally found a niche for themselves where they stand out – instead of just being a LEGO wannabe. If they could get the quality of their regular building elements at least near the quality of LEGO, maybe they would even gain the respect of more LEGO fans. But at least their Micro Action Figure packs are already making collectors happy.

Anyhow, that’s my story with Mega Bloks. What about you? Have you ever gotten any of their sets or figures? How do you like them? How would you compare their quality to LEGO? Feel free to share your thoughts and own review in the comment section below! 😉

And you might also like to check out the following related posts:

{ 30 comments }